So believe it or not a writer is asking for suggestions... I want to know what to write about...

my first idea is about a guy writing about the adventures he had with his persian. basically a slightly emo story of the finding of a meowth kitten, and over time the death of it... the boy struggles with his abusive father, twisted eldest bother,

my second idea is a guy in a tropical island with new pokemon including a two headed fire/ice snake pokemon. the guy is a typical trainer dreaming of being a gym leader...

medieval battles with pokemon. Kingdoms go to war, pigeot, and fearow, riders form the elite sky hunter patrol, and a pack of Aerodactyl and their riders form the elite dragon patrol... "every child dreams of being a sky hunter... every sky hunter wishes to be a dragon rider... every dragon rider wishes they were a child again..."

so please tell me what you think would be best, or if I should simply give up all together because all the ideas suck... but I DO have feelings, so please be a constructive criticizer

The idea is that we are far enough back that the aerodactyl, omastar, kabutops, etc. are not extinct yet, and although it does go against a lot of what was said about how long ago they lived, there were some in the pokemon episode where ash is at the dig site in the original series, and on top of that it is a fan fiction, so i can bend the rules as long as I state I have changed the rule before i write the story, so it shows i realize i changed the rules, and am not a noob.

They all sound like pretty good ideas. I'd like to read both the first and second one. My vote goes toward the gym leader one. That is, if by tropical island, you mean an Orange Island-esque gym where they each have their own unique battle methods. That'd be interesting to read, especially since it's also about a gym leader getting his start.